Quality Cataloguing – should we care?
Is good cataloguing really necessary?
Sorry, no pretty pictures on this blog, just something to ponder.
As a qualified archivist I knew cataloguing was important, but now as a full-time 'end user' as they call us in the strategic world, blimey, it is essential. But it has to be GOOD AND CONSISTENT cataloguing.
Unfortunately though, I am not sure that it is always given high priority among service leaders and purse-string holders - 'it's easy, we'll just get volunteers to do that' I once overheard. Cataloguing is often seen as back-room and it's not 'sexy' but it deserves to be one of the top priorities of any archive service. How else can anyone access the information in collections. It is also a task that needs to be managed and undertaken by qualified archivists (that is a core part of their training) or highly trained volunteers that are well supervised by those archivists.
Whether documents, film, photographs, maps, plans or other medium, how will I the 'end-user' or you, the service provider, know what is in your collections, if no adequate descriptions of your holdings exist. Good cataloguing is a professional skill, developed over time. As the cataloguer, not only do you need to be able read old handwriting and have good knowledge of the area you are serving, you also need to know what people (whether private, official, business or otherwise) using your service ask for. What do my customers tend to ask for? What are current trends in research? what anniversaries are coming up? What keywords do I need to put in? You need to get inside your users heads and ask yourself 'What from this document are they looking for?'. You can probably only answer these questions by keeping informed and working with your users through regular public service duty.
Many modern service users won't contact archives and other holders of manuscripts direct, they will check online catalogues on their phones, tablets, laptops and any other device imaginable - and the unimagined that are yet to be invented (won't be long!). If that catalogue is not coming back with results for searches, that remote user probably thinks the document, etc, that will answer his/her questions, doesn't exist. Bang! Right there, you've lost a customer. And remember, service providers, you don't know where your remote user is - could be here, could be Tasmania.
I recently undertook some research looking for documents relating to impressment into the Royal Navy during the Napoleonic War. Although not looking for any, I came across a hermaphrodite serving in 1828. By doing a search for this term, I came across other fascinating historic documents relating to hermaphrodites - I would never have found the first reference if deep and accurate cataloguing hadn't been undertaken. I think there's a blog there at a later date.
My plea to archive service providers, please, please enable trained professionals to aid good and consistent cataloguing, so that I and thousands like me can keep accessing our historic collections, and discover new and wonderful stories to share.