It’s just circumstantial – Sawrey Street, Plymouth

I thought I would share with you an example of lateral thinking, knowing the documentary sources, and just pure good luck (even the experts need a bit of that occasionally) when it comes to historical research. It is not always possible to prove a theory absolutely, but the circumstantial evidence may be strong enough to be convincing.
Sawrey Street, Plymouth. Never heard of it? I wouldn’t be surprised. It’s tucked away and runs parallel to the south side of Union Street. If you're local to Plymouth, you may have noticed ‘Docwra Brothers’ on a building at the eastern end as you drive towards the Octagon from Millbay. You wouldn’t know it was Sawrey Street as there is no road sign at this entrance to the street. Over a hundred years ago it dog-legged into Moir Street. But where did these names come from.
Sawrey is not a common surname ‘in these parts’, in fact there were very few in the latter part of the 19th century when these two streets start appearing. Sawrey, the place, is near Hawkshead in the Lake District. So why use the name in Devon? Here’s a theory. It’s a bit convoluted, but here goes.
By accident, I came across a baptism for a Miles Sawrey Derry in 1825 in Plymouth - parents David Derry and Susan Moyer. He and Susan Moyer Evens married in Charles Parish in 1816 by licence. Moir Street is adjacent to Sawrey Street (different spelling, but too much of a coincidence to ignore), and Derry was an important name in Plymouth's 19th century history. David Derry, as it turns out, was Lord Mayor of Plymouth 1850-1851, so quite influential. I also remembered the name Myles Sawrey from my first ‘delvings’.
David Derry's parents were Richard and Jane Derry and David was born 1794. Richard Derry married Jane Kirkby in St Andrew's in 1793.
I found a will for Myles Sawrey of Plymouth who died in 1796 aged 64 years. He was buried in the Baptist (or ‘dissenters’) burial ground in the town, as per the wishes stated in his will. In the will he mentions leaving copyhold estate and tenement at Coniston Water head (then in Lancashire) to his sister Agatha Kirkby, wife of David Kirkby, gentleman, of Thwaite in Coniston. He also mentions his niece Jane Derry, wife of Richard Derry (David's parents as above). Back to Myles Sawrey's baptism. He was born in Hawkshead, which is near Sawrey. Bingo!
It would need more work to really confirm, but all the evidence suggests that David Derry (or a member of the Derry family) gave the names Sawrey and Moir to the two new streets, and these names were taken from their family (as above). There is also the connection further back to Sawrey in Hawkshead, now in the Lake District in Cumbria (although still listed as Lancashire on family history sites). Further FH research would confirm whether the family took their name from the village of Near and Far Sawrey, but it seems pretty conclusive. A quick look on Ancestry shows that there are Sawrey family members in Hawkshead at least as far back to the 1560s.
So there you have it. One lucky clue and a strong theory has emerged. If I ever prove it absolutely (or if someone out there knows the answer absolutely) I’ll be sure to let you know.
The photograph is of the Docwr[a] Brothers building and the former Octagon Brewery Garage is at the eastern end of Sawrey Street. Unfortunately, the weather was not kind on the day I was there, so not an image of beauty I'm afraid.